I have no stance on this, and love that it could be either. Is he skirting by on coincidences that he runs into, or is he highly intelligent, observant and skilled, and lulls the perps into a false sense of security?
Have you watched it? Reasonably obvious that the idea is that he’s holding back to trip people into talking themselves in a story. Far, far too consistent and low key to even wonder if he’s just accidentally blurring out random thoughts on a ‘double back’ that just happen to be lucky guess.
I’ve seen it and always felt that there were circumstantial things that happened to him during the episode that contributed heavily into him catching the perp. The one I remember was one involving him going to the dentist by happenstance, that got him to finally get the killer.
I haven’t watched Columbo since I was in high school, so maybe I didn’t see the rest of his clever maneuvering, but that’s how I interpreted the show… either he was genius, or constantly surrounded by happenstance.
https://columbophile.com/2020/10/18/episode-review-columbo-uneasy-lies-the-crown/
A trip to his own dentist provides Columbo with food for thought when he subsequently bites and gashes the inside of his cheek before the novocaine injection wears off. The wound is a match for the one found on the inside of Evans’ cheek.
Seeking further inspiration, Columbo enlists Horace to help unravel how Corman could have poisoned Evans at a secret dental appointment. They can’t figure it out until a chance discussion about the dissolving coating of pills sets off a light bulb in the Lieutenant’s head. That’s how Corman killed Evans – he coated the digitalis, hid it in a cavity, and the coating wore away hours later when Evans was lying in sin with Lydia.
That one is an especially niche happenstance but a lot of things happen to a person during the day or week, and it takes a certain kind of mind to turn those little bits of information into insights that can help solve a murder. The director focuses us on the moments which will move the story, whether that’s the random person in the elevator or the parking ticket or the dentist appointment.
Also there’s a compression that’s necessary in episodic shows, especially those old ones people didn’t stream in a binge. In a realer world, Columbo’s cheekbite might have happened a month earlier but he’d remember it when he saw the victim’s wound. In a modern show they might even have it happen 3 episodes back, because they know you will remember it from yesterday, not having to hope you recall it a month later.
Columbo is a packrat of details, observations, nuances and coincidences. And he’s expert at making smug people uncomfortable without ever being rude or claiming to know more than he does.
Both. It’s both. Also, it’s fictional 😄
Columbo himself claimed that he was never as smart as the other detectives, so he worked harder and thought more in order to make up for it.
